Thursday, December 9, 2010

The Smartest Are Often the Least "Well-Behaved"



After reading an article about Bill Gates and other school dropouts who made it big, and the untold stories of all those who have become the unmentionables of society, I was pondering the students in my current field placement. I noticed the other day while I was working to analyze a lesson plan I presented (the same one that was splendid and not so splendid), that the students who were the most engaged in conversation and the most enthusiastic about sharing their ideas were the students who were the most likely to get in trouble. Two in particular stick out in my mind. Each of these students have something particularly wonderful to offer the class, and I wonder how to harness their amazing characteristics (wit, humor, useful sarcasm) and utilize them for their own good and that of their classmates; so often, these characteristics just get them in trouble in the classroom.

How do I embrace these students as individuals and encourage their spirits without letting their shining personalities disrupt other students who are not quite as "bright"?

2 comments:

  1. It's interesting that you bring this up. The same thing is going on at my placement. The students there that appear to be the most disruptive are actually some of the most intelligent students! And I notice this especially with the boys. I wonder if they are not being challenged enough, and that's why they are acting out. Or maybe they need more movement. My CT pointed out to me that a lot of the specials teachers don't like these students because they think they're acting out when really they are being sarcastic and letting their own sense of humor shine through! I really find it quite refreshing! For some reason people seem to think that students should just sit quietly and learn and speak only when called on. While it's important to have students quiet at times I highly disagree that it needs to be all the time. I think a little more freedom needs to be allowed in the classroom, and I think that we should challenge these students and listen to them. Of course, we shouldn't listen to only them, but I think that if a teacher is able to find and/or create a sense of equilibrium where every student can feel free to talk in discussions then it could be a really great learning environment!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great blog! This is so true! Remember we learned with Dr. Johnson that most of the time when a child is "Acting out" they are frustrated because they need to be challenged more.

    ReplyDelete